Solution 5.8
 
 

a) Viability of the proposal

Profit calculation Sales
€ 2.50
Variable cost
€ 0.92
Contribution per unit
€ 1.58
Total contribution
€ 237,000
Fixed cost
€ 180,000
Profit
€ 57,000
       

Break-even point

180,000
113,924 units € 284,810 revenue
1.58
Margin of safety 36,076 units € 90,190 revenue

The proposal is viable.

b) New proposal

Volume (150,000x 115%)
172,500
Contribution
€ 1.33
New contribution
€229,425
Fixed cost
€180,000
Profit
€ 49,425
(drop of €7,575 )  
Break-even point
135,338 units
(increase of 21,414 units)  

c) Recommendation

Yes, the fresh bread proposal should be adopted but not with the free cup of tea.

d) Other factors to consider:

  • Would the image of the outlet be affected?
  • Better service to existing customers or potential to attract new customers?
  • Would sales of prebaked bread be affected by the fresh baked bread?
  • Are the staff experience enough?
  • Can staff cope with the additional work?
  • Are there health and safety considerations?
  • Are there legal concerns that need to be addressed?